=====================================
I gotta say that I am right there with Bill Simmons on disagreeing with the fine folks at ESPN about the top 25 sports movies of the past 25 years. I mean, ok, YEAH number one was a no-brainer. HOOSIERS is just the ONLY movie that culd be number one... but here, look at the rest of these:
BEST SPORTS MOVIES
As selected by ESPN25's Expert Panel | BEST SPORTS MOVIES
As ranked by ESPN.com SportsNation users |
1. Hoosiers | 1. Hoosiers |
2. Raging Bull | 2. Caddyshack |
3. Field of Dreams | 3. Field of Dreams |
4. Bull Durham | 4. Rudy |
5. Caddyshack | 5. Major League |
6. The Natural | 6. The Natural |
7. Chariots of Fire | 7. Bull Durham |
8. Jerry Maguire | 8. Remember the Titans |
9. Seabiscuit | 9. Jerry Maguire |
10. Remember the Titans | 10. Raging Bull |
11. A League of Their Own | 11. White Men Can't Jump |
12. Eight Men Out | 12. Seabiscuit |
13. White Men Can't Jump | 13. League of Their Own |
14. Major League | 14. The Rookie |
15. Tin Cup | 15. Eight Men Out |
16. 61* | 16. Tin Cup |
17. The Hurricane | 17. 61* |
18. The Color of Money | 18. Chariots of Fire |
19. Finding Forrester | 19. The Hurricane |
20. The Rookie | 20. The Color of Money |
21. Ali | 21. Ali |
22. Bend it Like Beckham | 22. Finding Forrester |
23. Cobb | 23. Cobb |
24. Rudy | 24. Searching for Bobby Fischer |
25. Searching for Bobby Fischer | 25. Bend It Like Beckham |
Some of these make me wonder, why Ed isn't on this list. You know Ed... the sports classic starring Matt LeBlanc as a minor league pitcher who has a killer fast ball, but struggles with controlling his curve. So of course the team's overall play and Matt's pitching so dramatically improve when the team somehow manages to land a chimpanzee as a player... because that makes all kinds of sense. What? You didn't see that one? Well, that's ok, most people didn't see a lot of the other movies that made the official top 25.
Now here's the thing, I might have different criteria for what defines a sports movie, let alone one of the top 25 sports movies, but I think (and correct me if I'm wrong here,) that The Sandlot was much more qualified as a top ranking sports movie than Searching for Bobby Fischer. And if you're really looking to limit the number of baseball movies on the roster, then that's fine... leave Bobby Fischer and replace Cobb... nobody saw either one anyway, and if you're really attached to dark dramatic baseball stores, then that's fine, leave Cobb in and take out The Rookie... That way you replace one sappy, cheesy family-oriented baseball story with a movie that is an original, memorable, family-oriented baseball story. This is just a jumping off point, there are a lot of revisions to be made to the bottom 24 movies on the list... like I said Hoosiers stays at number one. Am I alone here? Am I the only one who thinks we need to construct the real list of the top 25 and let ESPN know what's up? I think I'm going to have to establish some kind of criteria for ranking and get this thing in the works. (Please feel free to suggest movies that make your top 25)
Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm going to go watch the E! True Hollywood Story: Jim Varney (Yeah, the guy who played Ernest.)
No comments:
Post a Comment